Review form – Ciencias de la Salud

 

Dear reviewer, please send this form via email to rev.cienc.salud@urosario.edu.co before the deadline provided in the message.

 

Manuscript title:

 

Please rate each of the manuscript’s elements and check the suitable category.

SCORE

Yes      No                   Unclear            Not available

Is the material original?

Is the information presented relevant?

Is the topic interesting from the health viewpoint?

Is it clearly written?

Is it brief?

Is the methodology well presented?

Are the results valid?

Is the discussion relevant?

Are the conclusions rational?

Are the figures and tables suitable?

1. General comments to the author

2. Recommendation (please choose one option):

 ___ Accepted without changes

___ Accepted with changes

___ Acceptable, with significant changes

___Not accepted.3. Comments to the editor (confidential)

Name:

Date: