REVISTA DE ECONOMÍA DEL ROSARIO

Peer Review Evaluation Form

1.     REVIEWER’S PERSONAL INFORMATION

The following information is required to certify and officially recognize your contribution within Colombia’s National Indexing System for Scientific Journals – Publindex (Minciencias). Your full name and country of nationality will be shared in the "Reviewer Information" section of the Revista de Economía del Rosario.

Full name:
Institutional affiliation:
ORCID:
ID Type and Number:
Date of birth (DD/MM/YY):
Country of nationality:

2. ETHICAL DISCLOSURE AND COMMITMENT

Please mark each box with an (X) to proceed with the evaluation.

• [ ] I declare that I have no conflicts of interest (personal, financial, or professional) regarding the authors or the research.
• [ ] I commit to maintaining the strict confidentiality of the manuscript.
• [ ] I certify that the critical analysis and technical judgment of this review are exclusively my own human authorship. I acknowledge that the authors have not authorized the processing of their work through Large Language Models (LLM) for this review phase. If applicable, I commit to disclosing any use of assistive tools in Section 4.
•  

3. TECHNICAL EVALUATION CRITERIA

Please rate the following criteria from 1 (Poor) to 5 (Excellent) by marking with an (X) as appropriate.

Evaluation Criterion	1	2	3	4	5
Originality: Does the article provide a novel contribution to the literature?
Methodological Rigor: Are the tools and methods appropriate?
Clarity and Structure: Are the language and logical flow precise?
Bibliographic Currency: Are the sources relevant and up to date?

4. COMMENTS AND OBSERVATIONS (MANDATORY)

Please detail the strengths and weaknesses of the text. Specify any required changes clearly to guide the author in their revisions.

 

 

5. FINAL RECOMMENDATION

Please select only one option with an (X):

• [ ] Accept Submission (Publishable as is).
• [ ] Publishable with Revisions (Minor or major changes required).
• [ ] Decine Submission (Not publishable).