Review Form

Review form - Territorios

Reviewer’s name:

Citizenship card or ID:

Date of assessment submission:

Manuscript title:

Dear reviewer,

 

Below you will find the criteria to be considered to issue your opinion on the manuscript subject to review. Please answer the questions or complete the requirements and mention your views, comments, and suggestions.

1. Overall concept

2. Comments on the submitted manuscript:

Which are the innovating contributions or aspects of the manuscript regarding the topic’s state of the art?

What is the quality of the analysis conducted?

What is your opinion of the methodological rigor?

Are the title and abstract consistent with the manuscript’s content and scope?

Do the conclusions correspond to, and are they in line with, the results obtained?

What is the style’s quality?

3. Recommendations in terms of the following:

  • content:
  • format (especially quotations, references, maps, charts, tables, etc.):

4. In your opinion, is the article suitable for publication?

  • YES, as it is: ______________
  • With minor modifications: ______________
  • NO ______________

 Reviewer’s signature: _____________________

Dear reviewer,

The Territorios journal aims to constantly improve its academic and editorial quality. Thus, we would like to ask you to kindly fill out the form below with the information requested, by considering the indexing guidelines.

The information detailed below will not be used for purposes other than indexing and information processes inherent to the Territorios journal.

We would like to thank you again for being part of the Territorios journal:

 

First Name(s)

 

Last name(s)

 

Nationality

 

Date of birth (mm-dd-yy)

 

City and country of residence

 

Identification Document Number (or Foreigner’s identity card)

 

Profession or occupation

 

Current institution

 

Department/Office

 

Type of institution*

 

Institution’s nature**

 

Institution’s city and country

 

Institution address

 

Corresponding author’s address and phone number***

 

Relevant working experience

 

Academic experience

 

Education level

 

Qualifications obtained–Institute or University

 

Email address

 

Scientific articles published (in the past 2 years)

 

Journal(s) of publication

 

* Higher education, association, firm, governmental, etc.

** Private, public, NGOs

*** Please do not forget to add the phone number as this is a requirement for national and international submissions to receive the pertinent correspondence.