Review format – Disertaciones

1.-Article details:

1.1 Title:

1.2 Date article received:

1.3 Date of submission to peer reviewer:

1.4 Peer reviewer’s return date:

2.- Aspects to be evaluated related to the objectives of DISERTACIONES:

No.	Objective-related items	Yes	No
1	Clarity in the thematic approach
2	Relation between the article contents and the concept of DISERTACIONES
3	Proof of subject mastery
4	Placement within any theme of interest of DISERTACIONES

3.- Aspects to be evaluated related to content.

No.	Content-related items	Yes	No
1	Coherent approach to ideas
2	The main idea can be identified
3	Approach originality
4	Mastery of specialized lexicon
5	Mastery of bibliographic and referential sources
6	Sufficient subject treatment
7	Exhaustive subject treatment

4.- Aspects to evaluate related to style and writing

No.	Style-related items	Yes	No
1	Logical discussion order
2	Coherence in relating approaches
3	Cohesion of discussion
4	Mastery of subject
5	Writing, spelling, and formal aspects

5.- Aspects to evaluate related to methodology

No.	Methodology-related items	Yes	No
1	Defined research methodology
2	Mastery of selected methodology
3	Relevant use of graphic resources and illustrations