Review Form

Review format - Desafíos

Thank you for accepting our invitation to review this manuscript for Desafíos. Your assessment and comments will be useful for authors and editors. We ask you to kindly send us your opinion within three weeks upon manuscript receipt so that we can share your feedback with authors. 

Manuscript identification

Title; Reviewer’s name; and Citizenship/foreign identity card and/or passport.

ORCID[1]; Submission date; and Return date

  1. Does the manuscript meet the typical formal requirements of scientific publications (abstract, keywords, references, etc.)? 

SECTION A (Comments for the managing editor and guest editors only)

  1. What is your overall opinion of the manuscript’s quality? Do you think that the content level is suitable for publication in a specialized scientific journal?

SECTION B (Recommendations for the manuscript’s authors)

  1. Manuscript assessment

Please list the remarks or suggestions targeted at the manuscript’s authors in this section. These will help the editor make a decision and aid authors toward understanding it. Therefore, your comments and suggestions must be objective, nonbiased, thorough, constructive, and systematic. Please use respectful, neutral, and constructive language, and only include general clarifications and specific examples.

  1. Where applicable, please include the changes suggested for the authors below:
  1. Final decision

Please mark the sentence that best summarizes your assessment of the potential publication of the manuscript.

The manuscript should be accepted for publication without modifications or with minor revisions.

 

After undergoing a revision process, the manuscript becomes a strong candidate for publication.

 

The manuscript would only be publishable if significant revisions were made.

 

Even after making significant revisions, the manuscript is not suitable for publication.

 

SECTION C (Reviewer’s information) 

The information provided herein will never be used other than to aid journal indexing and internal information processes.

Name(s)

 

Last name(s)

 

Nationality

 

Date of birth (dd-mm-yy)

 

City and country of residence

 

Identification Document Number

 

Profession or occupation

 

Current institution

 

Department/Office

 

Type of institution*

 

Institution’s nature**

 

Institution’s city and country

 

Institution address

 

Phone number

 

Qualifications obtained – Institute or University

 

Email address

 

Scientific articles published (in the past 2 years) and journal(s) of publication

 

*Higher education, association, business, government, etc.

** Private, public, or NGO

___________________________________________

Reviewer’s signature

[1] The citizenship/foreign identity card and/or passport and ORCID details are required by the Administrative Department of Science and Technology and Innovation of Colombia, Colciencias